Oversight Board/2010/Meeting Minutes-2010-03-05 - Revision history

Cjl: /* Log */

2011-03-02T04:32:01Z

Log

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:32, 2 March 2011
Line 44:		Line 44:
	== Log ==		== Log ==

	[[Oversight_Board/Meeting_Log-2010-03-05\|Meeting Log]]		[[Oversight_Board/2010/Meeting_Log-2010-03-05\|Meeting Log]]

	[[Category:Oversight board]]		[[Category:Oversight board]]
	[[Category:Meeting minutes]]		[[Category:Meeting minutes]]
	[[Category:Decision panels]]		[[Category:Decision panels]]

Cjl: moved Oversight Board/Meeting Minutes-2010-03-05 to Oversight Board/2010/Meeting Minutes-2010-03-05

2011-03-02T04:31:36Z

moved Oversight Board/Meeting Minutes-2010-03-05 to Oversight Board/2010/Meeting Minutes-2010-03-05

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:31, 2 March 2011
(No difference)

FGrose at 14:31, 10 July 2010

2010-07-10T14:31:59Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:31, 10 July 2010
Line 47:		Line 47:

	[[Category:Oversight board]]		[[Category:Oversight board]]
	~~[[Category:Meetings]]~~
	[[Category:Meeting minutes]]		[[Category:Meeting minutes]]
	[[Category:Decision panels]]		[[Category:Decision panels]]

Walter: /* ASLO */

2010-03-05T19:37:28Z

ASLO

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:37, 5 March 2010
Line 16:		Line 16:
	:Discussion of [http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.laptop.olpc.sugar/21243 Not fully bundled .xo] ASLO question<br>Request could be shorten to:		:Discussion of [http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.laptop.olpc.sugar/21243 Not fully bundled .xo] ASLO question<br>Request could be shorten to:
	:* Making a statement that current ASLO workflow is pretty unreliable, since ASLO is deployment agnostic, trying to bundle binaries to .xo is a fragile practice. At the same time taking one particular decision would either affect basic Sugar workflows (fully bundled .xo) or leave situation fragile.		:* Making a statement that current ASLO workflow is pretty unreliable, since ASLO is deployment agnostic, trying to bundle binaries to .xo is a fragile practice. At the same time taking one particular decision would either affect basic Sugar workflows (fully bundled .xo) or leave situation fragile.
	:* Thus it (could) require non-technical agreement to follow either ''"activities should not rely on non-SP dependencies and we should make it clear that we are not going to deploy Java/Qt/etc activities from ASLO"'' or ''"we will deploy Java/Qt/etc activities from ASLO and lets take the right tech decision (out of SLOBs) but (maybe) accept moratorium like [http://article.gmane.org/gmane.linux.laptop.olpc.sugar/21244] to not make situation worse until we take right technical decision."''		:* Thus it (could) require non-technical agreement to follow either (A) ''"activities should not rely on non-SP dependencies and we should make it clear that we are not going to deploy Java/Qt/etc activities from ASLO"'' or (B) ''"we will deploy Java/Qt/etc activities from ASLO and lets take the right tech decision (out of SLOBs) but (maybe) accept moratorium like [http://article.gmane.org/gmane.linux.laptop.olpc.sugar/21244] to not make situation worse until we take right technical decision."''
	:* [http://idea.olpcorps.net/ideatorrent/ideatorrent/idea/20/ Poll] results		:* [http://idea.olpcorps.net/ideatorrent/ideatorrent/idea/20/ Poll] results

Walter: Created page with 'In attendance: SLOB members: walter, tomeu, mchua, bernie, canoeberry, cjb Some community members (including alsroot, dogi) attended the meeting. == Agenda == # ASLO # Tradema…'

2010-03-05T19:36:45Z

Created page with 'In attendance: SLOB members: walter, tomeu, mchua, bernie, canoeberry, cjb Some community members (including alsroot, dogi) attended the meeting. == Agenda == # ASLO # Tradema…'

New page

In attendance:

SLOB members: walter, tomeu, mchua, bernie, canoeberry, cjb

Some community members (including alsroot, dogi) attended the meeting.

== Agenda ==
# ASLO
# Trademark policy
# Google Summer of Code
# Goals for 2010

=== ASLO ===
Aleksey (alsroot) solicited a policy statement from SLOB regarding the hosting of activity bundles with non-Sugar dependencies on activities.sugarlabs.org.

:Discussion of [http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.laptop.olpc.sugar/21243 Not fully bundled .xo] ASLO question<br>Request could be shorten to:
:* Making a statement that current ASLO workflow is pretty unreliable, since ASLO is deployment agnostic, trying to bundle binaries to .xo is a fragile practice. At the same time taking one particular decision would either affect basic Sugar workflows (fully bundled .xo) or leave situation fragile.
:* Thus it (could) require non-technical agreement to follow either ''"activities should not rely on non-SP dependencies and we should make it clear that we are not going to deploy Java/Qt/etc activities from ASLO"'' or ''"we will deploy Java/Qt/etc activities from ASLO and lets take the right tech decision (out of SLOBs) but (maybe) accept moratorium like [http://article.gmane.org/gmane.linux.laptop.olpc.sugar/21244] to not make situation worse until we take right technical decision."''
:* [http://idea.olpcorps.net/ideatorrent/ideatorrent/idea/20/ Poll] results

'''Motion:''' (1) Bundles with non-Sugar dependencies be clearly marked in ASLO; (2) We work towards a mechanism for supporting access to non-Sugar dependencies--a specific endorsement of being open; and (3) We do not restrict ASLO while we progress towards #2.

Approved: 4 in favor; 2 abstaining; 1 absent.

'''Action:''' mchua to write up a position statement regarding a policy of marking certain activities as '''supported''' for discussion at our next meeting.

=== Trademark ===
Walter made some edits to [[Talk:Sugar_Labs/Governance/Trademark#Sugar_Trademark_Policy|our draft trademark policy]] that bifurcated Section 2.a into no-written-approval required and written-approval required sections. It was a welcome change for those attending the meeting.

'''Action:''' Walter will discuss this proposed change with seandaly before the next meeting.

=== Google Summer of Code ===
It was just mentioned that Walter and Tim McNamara are working on our application. There was favorable reaction to a proposal to steer project proposals towards alignment with existing Sugar projects with existing open tickets.

=== Goals for 2010 ===
Not discussed due to lack of time.

'''Action:''' Walter to draft 5-year goals to parallel 1-year goals.

== Next meeting ==

Friday, 12 March 2010 16:00 UTC ('''Note:''' As usual, we will again be meeting one hour later than usual.)

== Log ==

[[Oversight_Board/Meeting_Log-2010-03-05|Meeting Log]]

[[Category:Oversight board]]
[[Category:Meetings]]
[[Category:Meeting minutes]]
[[Category:Decision panels]]