Decision panels: Difference between revisions

Line 1:

'''Decision panels''' are defined [[Sugar Labs/Governance#Decision Panels|in the Sugar Labs governance ~~documents~~]] as temporary bodies set up to study a specific controversial or politically sensitive issue, and produce a report about their conclusions as a recommendation to the Oversight Board. They are formed by a decision of the Oversight Board, generally after a call for volunteers, and given specific topics and questions to address.

'''Decision panels''' are defined [[Sugar Labs/Governance#Decision Panels|in the Sugar Labs rules of governance]] as temporary bodies set up to study a specific controversial or politically sensitive issue, and produce a report about their conclusions as a recommendation to the Oversight Board. They are formed by a decision of the Oversight Board, generally after a call for volunteers, and given specific topics and questions to address.

From the Rules of Governance draft as of September 2009:

On the rare occasion of a contentious issue on which no general consensus can be reached, the Oversight Board is responsible for convening a Decision Panel. The Oversight Board will be responsible for determining when a Decision Panel is required and for selecting members for the Decision Panel. Members of the Oversight Board are not permitted to serve on a Decision Panel. A Decision Panel will solicit community input, discuss (in private if they deem it necessary), reach a conclusion internally, and produce a report documenting their conclusion. (Anyone may submit advice to a Decision Panel.) The Oversight Board will review and ratify Decision Panel reports.

</div>

</blockquote>

== Ben on the origins of the idea ==

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-'''Decision panels''' are defined [[Sugar Labs/Governance#Decision Panels|in the Sugar Labs governance documents]] as temporary bodies set up to study a specific controversial or politically sensitive issue, and produce a report about their conclusions as a recommendation to the Oversight Board.  They are formed by a decision of the Oversight Board, generally after a call for volunteers, and given specific topics and questions to address.
+'''Decision panels''' are defined [[Sugar Labs/Governance#Decision Panels|in the Sugar Labs rules of governance]] as temporary bodies set up to study a specific controversial or politically sensitive issue, and produce a report about their conclusions as a recommendation to the Oversight Board.  They are formed by a decision of the Oversight Board, generally after a call for volunteers, and given specific topics and questions to address.
+From the Rules of Governance draft as of September 2009:
+<blockquote>
+<div style="border:1px solid gray; padding:6px; margin:4px; font-size:80%"; background-color:white; color:#333;">
+On the rare occasion of a contentious issue on which no general consensus can be reached, the Oversight Board is responsible for convening a Decision Panel. The Oversight Board will be responsible for determining when a Decision Panel is required and for selecting members for the Decision Panel. Members of the Oversight Board are not permitted to serve on a Decision Panel. A Decision Panel will solicit community input, discuss (in private if they deem it necessary), reach a conclusion internally, and produce a report documenting their conclusion. (Anyone may submit advice to a Decision Panel.) The Oversight Board will review and ratify Decision Panel reports.
+</div>
+</blockquote>
 == Ben on the origins of the idea ==