243
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 8:
Line 8: − + − + − + − + − + Line 29:
Line 29: − + Line 74:
Line 74: − + Line 87:
Line 87: − + − + − + − + − + Line 107:
Line 107: − + Line 133:
Line 133: − + Line 151:
Line 151: − Yes: + + + + + + + + + + − + − − No: − − Undecided:+ − + − + − Unknown: − Line 174:
Line 178: + + − + − Yes:+ − + + + + + + + − No:+ − − + − + − + − Undecided: − − − Unknown: Line 201:
Line 208: + + − Yes:+ − + + + + + + + + − + − + − No: − − Undecided:+ + + − − − Unknown: Line 226:
Line 239: + + Line 231:
Line 246: − +
reformat voting results as wiki tables
{{quote|
{{quote|
:"Investigate the situation of how SoaS should be treated by Sugar Labs, and related questions, including answers to the following:
:"Investigate the situation of how SoaS should be treated by Sugar Labs, and related questions, including answers to the following:
:* "Should Sugar Labs be a GNU/Linux distributor, rather than just an upstream producing Sugar releases?"
:* "Should Sugar Labs be a GNU/Linux distributor, rather than just an upstream producing Sugar releases?"
:* "Should SL be neutral about distributions containing Sugar, and refuse to endorse one over another?"
:* "Should SL be neutral about distributions containing Sugar, and refuse to endorse one over another?"
:* "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
:* "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
:* Any other question the Decision Panel deems required to provide an answer to the original question:"Is the current SoaS going to be the primary way Sugar Labs distributes a Sugar-centric GNU/Linux distribution?"
:* Any other question the Decision Panel deems required to provide an answer to the original question:"Is the current SoaS going to be the primary way Sugar Labs distributes a Sugar-centric GNU/Linux distribution?"
}}
}}
* Caryl Bigenho
* Caryl Bigenho
* Daniel Drake
* Daniel Drake
* Abhishek Indoria
* Abhishek Indoria
Question 3: "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
Question 3: "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
Answer: Yes.
Answer: Yes.
{{quote|
{{quote|
:"Investigate the situation of how SoaS should be treated by Sugar Labs, and related questions, including answers to the following:
:"Investigate the situation of how SoaS should be treated by Sugar Labs, and related questions, including answers to the following:
:* "Should Sugar Labs be a GNU/Linux distributor, rather than just an upstream producing Sugar releases?"
:* "Should Sugar Labs be a GNU/Linux distributor, rather than just an upstream producing Sugar releases?"
:* "Should SL be neutral about distributions containing Sugar, and refuse to endorse one over another?"
:* "Should SL be neutral about distributions containing Sugar, and refuse to endorse one over another?"
:* "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
:* "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
:* Any other question the Decision Panel deems required to provide an answer to the original question:"Is the current SoaS going to be the primary way Sugar Labs distributes a Sugar-centric GNU/Linux distribution?"
:* Any other question the Decision Panel deems required to provide an answer to the original question:"Is the current SoaS going to be the primary way Sugar Labs distributes a Sugar-centric GNU/Linux distribution?"
}}
}}
* Caryl Bigenho
* Caryl Bigenho
* Daniel Drake
* Daniel Drake
* Abhishek Indoria
* Abhishek Indoria
Question 3: "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
Question 3: "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
Answer: Yes.
Answer: Yes.
=====Question 1=====
=====Question 1=====
{|
|+ Question 1: "Should Sugar Labs be a GNU/Linux distributor, rather than just an upstream producing
Sugar releases?"
! Yes
! No
! Defer
! Invalid
! Undecided/Abstain
|-
|
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000100.html Sean Daly]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000100.html Sean Daly]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000029.html Bill Bogstead]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000029.html Bill Bogstead]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000149.html Abhishek Indoria]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000149.html Abhishek Indoria]
|
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000028.html Martin Dengler]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000028.html Martin Dengler]
# Tabitha Roder
# Tabitha Roder
# Caryl Bigenho
# Caryl Bigenho
|
|
|
# Sebastian Dziallas
# Sebastian Dziallas
# Luke Faraone
# Luke Faraone
# Samuel Klein
# Samuel Klein
# Daniel Drake
# Daniel Drake
|}
=====Question 2=====
=====Question 2=====
{|
|+ Question 2: "Should SL be neutral about distributions containing Sugar, and refuse to endorse one over another?"
! For
! Against
! Defer
! Invalid
! Undecided/Abstain
|-
|
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000028.html Martin Dengler]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000028.html Martin Dengler]
# Tabitha Roder
# Tabitha Roder
# Caryl Bigenho
# Caryl Bigenho
|
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000149.html Abhishek Indoria]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000149.html Abhishek Indoria]
|
|
|
# Sebastian Dziallas
# Sebastian Dziallas
# Luke Faraone
# Luke Faraone
# Samuel Klein
# Samuel Klein
# Daniel Drake
# Daniel Drake
|}
=====Question 3=====
=====Question 3=====
{|
|+ Question 3: "Should 'Sugar on a Stick' be a phrase that SL asks its community to avoid using unless they refer to the SoaS-Fedora distribution?"
! For
! Against
! Defer
! Invalid
! Undecided/Abstain
|-
|
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000045.html Sean Daly]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000045.html Sean Daly]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000149.html Abhishek Indoria]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-October/000149.html Abhishek Indoria]
# Tabitha Roder
# Tabitha Roder
|
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000028.html Martin Dengler]
# [http://lists.sugarlabs.org/archive/soas/2009-September/000028.html Martin Dengler]
# Caryl Bigenho
# Caryl Bigenho
|
|
|
# Bill Bogstad (dependent on answer to question #1)
# Bill Bogstad (dependent on answer to question #1)
# Sebastian Dziallas
# Sebastian Dziallas
# Luke Faraone
# Luke Faraone
# Daniel Drake
# Daniel Drake
# Abhishek Indoria
# Abhishek Indoria
|}
====Further ideas====
====Further ideas====
=====Potential naming conventions=====
=====Potential naming conventions=====
* Sugar4CD/PC/F11 (Sugar, version 4, made for liveCD, runs on PCs, Fedora11 based) - example from Caryl Bigenho <cbigenho@hotmail.com>
* Sugar4CD/PC/F11 (Sugar, version 4, made for liveCD, runs on PCs, Fedora11 based) - example from Caryl Bigenho <cbigenho@hotmail.com>
* There has been much talk of whether we should name with different foods and animals. Types of sugar (sucrose, glucose) has been suggested due to its link to sustainability of life.
* There has been much talk of whether we should name with different foods and animals. Types of sugar (sucrose, glucose) has been suggested due to its link to sustainability of life.
There still seems to be much sense in keeping it simple with SoaS keeping one name with a version release number and corresponding release name.
There still seems to be much sense in keeping it simple with SoaS keeping one name with a version release number and corresponding release name.
* Perhaps including the type of media in the name could be helpful, but with "sugar" themes. For example SD versions could be "Sugar Cookies," Live CD versions could be "Sugar Pies." That would make the above example "SugarPie4/PC/F11"(also from Caryl Bigenho)
* Perhaps including the type of media in the name could be helpful, but with "sugar" themes. For example SD versions could be "Sugar Cookies," Live CD versions could be "Sugar Pies." That would make the above example "SugarPie4/PC/F11"(also from Caryl Bigenho)